Average Customer Review:
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
 Comparison of the 3 SS sippy cupsDec 31, 2009
I own all 3 stainless sippy cups - the Kleen Kanteen, the Thermos Foogoo, and the Safe Sippy. Conclusion: each has its specific use that it is best for. I use the Kleen Kanteen for water, the Foogoo for milk (so my daughter knows what drink she is getting). I like Safe Sippy the least.
My daughter is 17 months and has been using a sippy cup since 5 months.
Kleen Kanteen - 5 stars - my go-to cup and favorite of the three
Pros:
* Easy to assemble and clean (I wash it every day with hot soapy water and a nipple brush to avoid anything growing in the spout)
* Takes the Avent spouts
* Does NOT leak either from the valve or the threads (note to people who say that it just lets water run out - make sure you put the clear valve on the inside!). Also does not leak when she drops it or shakes it.
* You can put a can koozie around it if you need insulation!!!
* Lifelong purchase - When they don't need a sippy anymore, switch out the top.
Cons:
* The black plastic collar that screws in place has broken 4 (Yes! FOUR!) times when my daughter has dropped it. Costs at least $4.50 to replace. Has broken each time on a linoleum floor!
* My daughter has dented the bottom by banging it on the concrete outside. (not really a big deal, just aesthetically not as nice anymore)
* Mine did not come with a lid.
Thermos Foogoo - 3 stars - daily use for milk - great for outings but started leaking after ~4 months
Pros:
* The thermos construction keeps milk cold for hours!
* My daughter has dropped this one (or thrown it) and it does not break and only leaks a little milk from the spout (none from the threads).
Cons: Complicated!!! Read the directions!!!
* Valve is 2 pieces, difficult to remove, and don't loose either piece!
* Lid is 2 pieces, can be difficult to align.
* Lid pieces must be aligned perfectly and must be screwed in perfectly (spout exactly 90 degrees from the handles) so that it does not leak from the threads.
* My daughter has dented it.
Other comments:
* When my daughter was younger I liked the smaller volume - a larger size would have been too heavy and my daughter did not drink more than 7 oz of milk at once. Now she drinks more, and a larger cup would be nice. I guess now I just need to take a regular thermos of milk, and a separate sippy cup.
* It did not leak from the spout or threads for many months, as long as it was properly assembled, even if it was stored sideways. However, after 4 months of use, it now leaks a bit. If I put it in my bag, I put the cup in a Ziploc first.
Safe Sippy - 3 stars - Leaky so I use as a backup cup for water - I like the straw that comes with it (would have rated it 2 stars if there was no straw)
Pros:
* Handle is removable (Its kind of cheap and gets in the way, might be useful for the youngest kids)
* Switch out the inside valve with a straw! This is cool - I taught my daughter how to use the straw, so when she is older we will use this cup more.
* Rubber around the outside, so no need for a koozie.
Cons: Leaky! Leaky! Leaky!
* I wonder if the valve on this thing is just inconsistent between each bottle. Mine leaks when it is upside down and my daughter stops drinking and the pressure equalizes. It also leaks if its upside down and gets shaken at all. Some folks complain that it is too hard to get any water out, and others say it is perfect.
* The threads do not leak
* The o-ring is hard to get in and out to clean and you must be careful not to break it in the process.
 Very, VERY disappointedOct 08, 2009
I had been looking for a nice, sturdy sippy that would hold up to my 1-year-old's bad habit of throwing his cups from his crib. I'm also BPA conscious, so this seemed like a good choice. I mean, it's hard to crack stainless steel, right?
I purchased a blue one from BabiesRUs for about $12 or so. For the first couple uses this thing worked fine. Then I noticed that the little ring gasket kept coming out. I looked up info on the Safe Sippy's website FAQ page. I read the careful instructions on how to put it in place and I tried several times to insert it correctly. It still kept coming loose! Then I experimented with handwashing and putting it in the dishwasher and discovered that if I handwashed it AND let it air dry, then the gasket stayed in place fine. First problem was solved, but a little bit of a pain to have to handwash it and wait for it to air dry.
A few uses after I got that problem fixed the stupid valve started coming out of the spout and caused the cup to leak everywhere. I again thought that the handwash/air dry combo would keep it in place but alas, IT NEVER HAS. I have stupidly put this cup back in my cabinet several times and forgot the frustration of the leaking after a week or two went by of not using it.
Most recently, dumb me decided to bring it along to the library and I put it in a bag with some books. A little while later I'm sure you can imagine how totally ridiculous I felt as I was in the middle of the children's section with, literally, a PUDDLE of milk at my feet and a steady stream of it coming from my bag. The DUMB VALVE FELL OUT AGAIN!!!! The cup had only been in use for about an hour!!! UGHHH!!! I HATE THIS CUP! I'm throwing it away and wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. Please don't waste your money!
Wheeew. There. I feel better now.
 I LOVE THIS CUPOct 05, 2009
I love this cup and so does my son. I believe the bad reviews are due to the lack of understanding how to put the cup together. I learned that most problems with Travel Mugs and Sippy Cups are user error. I have thrown out SO many travel coffee mugs that leaked until I realized it was my own faullt. This cup has two very important components to it. One - the ring in the top of the lid - it must be in place. After putting through the dishwasher the ring will move - just needs to be adjusted. The second component is the stopper - it must be pushed in all the way. Once those two things are securely in place - you can shake, throw, and bounce this thing and it does not leak. It has not for me anyway. Enjoy!
Another leaking sippy cup: ho-humSep 11, 2009
So excited to find the safe sippy! cute design! rubber grip!
leaks. leaks badly. leaves a puddle anywhere it happens to be tipped over on it's side. leaks when my child tilts it toward him and misses his mouth. leaks if he is holding it and turns around fast in a circle.
leaks, leaks, leaks.
The BEST sippy cup ever!Aug 19, 2009
I have bought every BPA free, stainless steel, aluminum, you name it sippy cup out there, and this one is the best. Doesn't leak, doesn't dent. My kids love these cups!
|
based on 18 reviews
